Introduction

Under section 10 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, the essential ingredients required for making an agreement a contract have been stated. As per section 10, “All agreements are contracts if they are made by the free consent of parties competent to contract, for a lawful consideration and with a lawful object, and are not hereby expressly declared to be void.” Each of these is important and helps in ascertaining the validity of a contract.

First of all, there has to be a legal offer and acceptance so as to form a clear consensus ad idem, or meeting of minds, between the two parties. Secondly, the two parties have to be competent to contract as provided in section 11 of the Act. They have to be of the age of majority, of sound mind, and not disqualified by law. An agreement made with a minor or a person of unsound mind is void ab initio.

Another essential is that there must be "free consent" as provided by Section 14 of this Act. Consent is said to be "free" where it is not caused by: Coercion; Undue influence; Fraud; Misrepresentation; or Mistake. Any contract made without "free consent" is voidable at the discretion of the party aggrieved. Moreover, there must be "lawful consideration" and "lawful object" as provided by Sections 23 and 24 of this Act. Any contract that is unlawful or against morality or violates public policy is void.

Finally, the Contract must not expressly be declared void under an Act, for instance, an agreement that is illegal under agreements that restrain trade, marriage, and others. Taking all these keys into account, it is certain that all these requirements make a contract fair, legal, and certain.

Meaning of Contract

A contract is a binding agreement that constitutes the cornerstone of all business and personal transactions in a wider social panorama. A contract governs transactions in a manner that states the rights, obligations, and duties of the involved parties. By forming binding promises, a contract instils certainty as well as trust in transactions. It is critical to comprehend the concept of a contract since it enables a person to understand when a contract is legally binding with the assistance of the law in all transactions.

Definition of Contract under Section 2(h)

The definition of contract has been defined under Section 2(h) of the Indian Contract Act 1872 and is given below:

“A contract is an agreement enforceable by law.”

This definition emphasises two crucial parts:

1. There has to be an agreement, and there has to be an exit

2. The contract should be enforceable.

An agreement is not a contract in itself. For an agreement to be a contract, it should obtain legal recognition and the force of law. Now, the most important aspect or ingredient for an agreement to be a contract is legal enforceability.

Section 10 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872

Section 10, Indian Contract Act, 1872: The section states certain conditions that need to be fulfilled so that an agreement becomes enforceable. It gives a basis for a law that requires contracts to be valid under Indian law.

According to Section 10:

All agreements are contracts if they are made by the free consent of parties competent to contract, for a lawful consideration and with a lawful object, and are not hereby expressly declared to be void.

This section clearly mentions that not all agreements are considered contracts. Only those agreements that meet all the requirements pointed out under section 10 are declared as valid contracts, as stated by law.

Section 10 lays down that in order to be a valid contract, the agreement must be arrived at voluntarily and with parties capable of contracting, based on legal consideration and legal object, and cannot be of any sort of agreement which is declared to be void under the Act.

Thus, section 10 constitutes the legal standard of enforceability, ensuring that only fair, lawful, and genuine contracts are bestowed with legal recognition and protection.

Essentials of a Valid Contract under Section 10

Section 10 of The Indian Contract Act, 1872 prescribes that it is necessary to fulfil basic requirements to make an agreement enforceable under the law in terms of a contract. The requirements necessary to fulfil are termed the essentials of a valid contract. The absence of any single factor prevents an agreement from becoming a contract under the law.

The necessary ingredients of a valid contract, provided in section 10, are explained below:

1. Agreement (Offer and Acceptance)

The initial requirement of a valid contract is called “agreement.” An “agreement” arises whenever one party delivers a lawful “offer” and the other party delivers a lawful “acceptance” of the offer. This “acceptance” must be absolute and given to the party making the “offer.”

There can be no agreement without the offer and acceptance, and thus there can be no contract.

2. Free Consent

A contract shall be considered valid only if the consent of the parties is free. According to the Indian Contract Act, consent is deemed to be free when it is not caused by coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation, or mistake.

In the absence of free consent, a contract becomes voidable at the discretion of the wronged party.

3. Competency of Parties

The persons entering into a contract must be competent to contract. As per law, an individual is competent to contract if:

1. He or she has reached the age of majority,

2. has a sound mind,

3. is not disqualified by law.

If the party contracting is a minor, an idiot, or a lunatic, the contract will be deemed void.

4. Lawful Consideration

Consideration is often defined as a return for a promise. For a contract to be legal, it must be based on legal consideration. A contract lacking consideration or containing unlawful consideration is not legal, although there are a few exceptions to such a rule.

5. Lawful Object

The object of the agreement needs to be legal. If the object of an agreement is illegal, immoral, or against public policy, then the agreement becomes void.

6. Agreement Not Expressly Declared Void

 A contract has to be a valid contract if it does not come within the ambit of the list of agreements which are declared as void in the Indian Contract Act. Even if all other requirements are satisfied, wagering agreements or any agreement in the restrained trade are not enforceable.

Other Essential Elements Recognised by Law

Although the factors mentioned in Section 10 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, are quite adequate to make a contract valid, the Indian judiciary has also discovered certain factors that are necessary in making a contract legal. These factors are not explicitly mentioned in Section 10 but are essential in ensuring that any contract entered into is a serious and binding activity so that any frivolous claims are averted.

Intention to create legal relations is one of the most significant additional essentials. In order to make an agreement legally binding, it must be between parties who have the intention to create a legal relationship. Lack of such an intention makes the contract nothing more than a social agreement/moral contract. Indian courts, in most general circumstances, assume that in domestic and social agreements, such as those between members of the same family and between friends, an agreement will not create any legal rights and duties, unless the contrary is proved, and that an intention to create legal rights was established. However, business agreements, being in nature, having an economic background, will be assumed to bear an intention to create legal relations.

Another relevant consideration is the certainty of terms. The terms of a valid contract should be certain and capable of being understood. Section 29 of the Indian Contract Act states that an agreement is void if the meaning of the agreement is not certain and cannot be ascertained. Courts will not give any force to an agreement that is not certain because the courts will be unable to determine the legal relationship between the parties to an agreement. Such determinations are critical to ensure that both parties are aware of the agreement they are entering into and to make its enforcement possible in case of a breach.

The possibility of performance: This is another doctrine that must be fulfilled for an agreement to be valid. This means that an agreement that is supposed to do an impossible thing, both physically and legally, leads to unenforceable rights. If impossibility occurs at the time of creating an agreement, it leads to a void agreement from its inception. This is because there is a basis in logic and fairness that an impossible thing cannot be compelled by law.

Absence of mistake is another significant consideration. The contract shall be rendered void in case both parties are in a mistake of fact, as to a fundamental aspect of the contract, or as to the existence or identity of the subject matter of a contract. As laws distinguished between mistake of fact and mistake of law, they merely admit the existence of the latter as a ground for voiding the contract in case the parties were at a mutual mistake of fact, and this is fundamental.

 Lastly, in case the law so requires, there must be observance of legal formalities for enforceability. While most contracts can be oral ones, in writing, in some cases, by necessity, where specific statutory formalities are required, like being in writing, registered, or authenticated, among others, not following these requirements would make the contract unenforceable. These additional considerations, put together, strengthen the foundation of the contract by promoting certainty, legality, and fairness in contract transactions.

Illustrative Example of a Valid Contract

To explain the application of Section 10 of the Indian Contract Act of 1872, take the following example. A sells his laptop to B for a price of ₹40,000, and B purchases the laptop from A for the same price. Both A and B are adults, and the agreement was reached without either of them being coerced or subjected to fraud, misrepresentation, or other void elements. Additionally, the agreement is worthwhile, and the terms of the agreement are possible to achieve. As all that is required of a contract as per Section 10 is satisfied, the said agreement forms a valid contract that can be enforced by the law of the land.

Importance of Section 10

The Indian Contract Act of 1872 – Section 10: This section is very crucial for the determination of the legal efficacy of contracts. This section describes the essential terms that the contract must comply with if the contracts are to be legally enforceable. It can be considered as an insurance against illegal, unjust, or involuntary contracts.

This is to ensure that contracts are made through the free consent of competent parties, for lawful consideration, and with lawful object. The provision safeguards an individual against contracts that are entered into through fraud and/or undue influence, thus ensuring that all matters pertaining to contracts have an element of fairness and justice.

Section 10 also provides legal certainty when it comes to transactions in businesses or personal issues because it establishes a clear distinction between contracts that are legally enforceable and contracts that are not legally binding. A court uses section 10 as a tool in determining the validity of a contract.

In this way, section 10 is the foundation of contract law in India, which states that every legal and bona fide contract must be accorded legal recognition.

Conclusion

Contracts are the backbone of personal as well as business transactions. Contracts offer a safeguard under which the contracting parties are able to carry out transactions among each other. Agreements are entered into every day; it does not mean that every agreement is capable of being enforced as a contract under the law. According to Section 10 of the Indian Contract Act of 1872, there are some special conditions required to convert ‘Agreement’ into ‘Valid and Legal Contract.’

As provided under Section 10, a contract is subject to the agreement reached after free consent, which means that the parties to a contract must enter into the contract voluntarily, not through coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation, or mistake. The parties to a contract must be competent to contract, in the sense that they must be of majority age, of sound mind, etc. The agreement reached must be lawful in consideration and in object, which means that the transaction is not illegal, immoral, or opposed to public policy. The agreement must not be expressly declared to be void by law.

Apart from the above requirements that exist under the law, there exist still more requirements that are recognised under contract law, and they include certainty, possibility of performance, and intent to create a contract. To be informed of the above requirements is one way that individuals, as well as business organisations, can stay clear of conflicts and make proper judgments. In conclusion, section 10 above can be said to be the basis under which contract law operates in the Indian nation.

Disclaimer: This article is intended solely for educational and informational purposes. It does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy, reliability, and completeness of the information provided, ClearLaw.online, the author, and the publisher disclaim any liability for errors, omissions, or inadvertent inaccuracies. Readers are strongly advised to consult a qualified legal professional for guidance on any specific legal issue or matter.